Encyclopediav1

Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR)

Last updated:

Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR)

The temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR), often denoted as α, is a fundamental electrical property that quantifies the relative change in the electrical resistance of a material per unit change in temperature [2]. It is a critical parameter in materials science and electrical engineering, describing how a material's resistivity responds to thermal fluctuations. TCR is typically expressed in units of parts per million per degree Celsius (ppm/°C) or per kelvin (K⁻¹), with the kelvin being the SI base unit of thermodynamic temperature defined in terms of fundamental constants [4][5]. Materials are broadly classified by the sign of their TCR: positive temperature coefficient (PTC) materials, where resistance increases with temperature, and negative temperature coefficient (NTC) materials, where resistance decreases with temperature [2][8]. Understanding TCR is essential for designing and selecting materials for components where stable electrical performance across a temperature range is required, such as in precision resistors, sensors, and integrated circuits. The magnitude and sign of the TCR are intrinsic material properties determined by the charge carrier mobility and concentration, which are in turn influenced by atomic structure and bonding [2]. For most pure metals, resistance increases linearly with temperature over a standard range, yielding a positive TCR, due to increased phonon scattering of conduction electrons [2]. In contrast, semiconductors and insulators often exhibit a negative TCR because rising temperature increases the number of charge carriers available for conduction [2]. Special alloys are formulated to achieve a near-zero TCR for applications demanding high stability; for instance, some precision metal film resistors are specified to change less than a defined tolerance, such as 0.1%, over their operating range [6][7]. The coefficient itself can be calculated from the material's resistivity at different temperatures, and its value can be significantly affected by the thermal expansion of supporting substrates, as demonstrated in flexible electronics where polymeric materials influence overall device sensitivity [1]. TCR is a cornerstone consideration in a vast array of applications. Precision resistors with low TCR are indispensable in measurement equipment, voltage references, and analog circuits to ensure accuracy [6]. Conversely, materials with a high, predictable TCR are exploited intentionally in temperature sensors, such as resistance temperature detectors (RTDs) using platinum (PTC) and thermistors (typically NTC) [8]. In semiconductor devices, TCR impacts the thermal management and performance stability of transistors and integrated circuits. The modern relevance of TCR extends to emerging fields like flexible and wearable electronics, where the interaction between functional materials and polymeric substrates creates complex thermal behaviors that must be characterized and managed [1]. Consequently, the measurement, specification, and conversion of TCR values—for example, between ppm/°C and K⁻¹—remain routine and vital engineering practices [3][5].

Overview

The Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR) is a fundamental material property that quantifies the rate at which the electrical resistance of a substance changes with temperature. It is formally defined as the relative change in resistance per degree of temperature change, typically expressed in units of parts per million per degree Celsius (ppm/°C) or as a percentage per degree Celsius (%/°C). The TCR is a critical parameter in the design and application of all electronic components and systems, as it determines the stability and predictability of circuit behavior across varying thermal environments [14]. The underlying physical principle is that the resistivity (ρ) of a material, which is an intrinsic property, is temperature-dependent. This temperature dependence arises from changes in charge carrier mobility and concentration with thermal energy [13].

Definition and Mathematical Formulation

The TCR is mathematically defined using the first-order approximation of resistance change with temperature. For a given material, the resistance R(T)R(T) at a temperature TT can be expressed in relation to its resistance R0R_0 at a reference temperature T0T_0 (often 20°C or 25°C) by the equation:

R(T)=R0[1+α(TT0)]R(T) = R_0 [1 + \alpha (T - T_0)]

where α\alpha is the linear temperature coefficient of resistance. The coefficient α\alpha is calculated as:

α=1R0dRdT\alpha = \frac{1}{R_0} \frac{dR}{dT}

In practical applications, especially over wider temperature ranges, a quadratic term is sometimes included to account for non-linearity:

R(T)=R0[1+α(TT0)+β(TT0)2]R(T) = R_0 [1 + \alpha (T - T_0) + \beta (T - T_0)^2]

where β\beta is the second-order temperature coefficient. The TCR value can be positive (PTC), negative (NTC), or approximately zero, depending on the material's electronic structure [13][14].

Positive and Negative Temperature Coefficients

Materials exhibit distinct behaviors categorized by the sign of their TCR.

  • Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC): Most pure metals and many alloys display a PTC, meaning their resistance increases with increasing temperature. This occurs because rising thermal energy increases lattice vibrations (phonons), which in turn scatter conducting electrons more effectively, reducing their mean free path and increasing resistivity. For example, the resistive element in precision metal plate resistors is often a special alloy comprising several different metals, formulated to achieve a specific, stable, and low positive TCR [13].
  • Negative Temperature Coefficient (NTC): Semiconductors, ceramics, and certain polymers often exhibit an NTC, where resistance decreases as temperature rises. In these materials, increased thermal energy excites more charge carriers (electrons and holes) into the conduction band, significantly increasing carrier concentration and outweighing the effects of reduced mobility. NTC thermistors are a primary application of this property [14].

Material Dependence and Typical Values

The magnitude and sign of TCR are intrinsically linked to material composition and structure.

  • Metals and Alloys: Pure metals like copper and aluminum have relatively high positive TCRs (around +3900 ppm/°C and +4000 ppm/°C, respectively). For precision applications, special low-TCR alloys are developed. For instance, the alloy manganin (Cu-Mn-Ni) has a TCR very close to zero (±20 ppm/°C), making it ideal for precision resistors and measurement standards. The specific alloy used in metal plate resistors is engineered to provide mechanical stability and a predictable, low TCR [13].
  • Semiconductors and Ceramics: Intrinsic semiconductors like silicon have a strong negative TCR. NTC thermistor ceramics, typically composed of transition metal oxides like manganese, nickel, and cobalt, can have large negative TCR values on the order of -30,000 to -60,000 ppm/°C, making them highly sensitive temperature sensors [14].
  • Superconductors: A special case exists where certain materials exhibit a sudden drop in resistance to zero below a critical temperature (Tc), representing an extreme negative coefficient at the transition point.

Influence of External Factors and Damage Mechanisms

The TCR of a component is not only a material property but can be influenced by its construction, operating conditions, and physical degradation.

  • Substrate and Mechanical Stress: The thermal expansion of supporting materials can induce mechanical stress in the resistive element, altering its effective TCR. Research on surface acoustic wave devices has demonstrated this effect starkly. A Rayleigh wave device on a rigid substrate exhibited a temperature coefficient of frequency (TCF, an analogous parameter) of 59 ppm/°C. In contrast, the same device on a flexible polymeric substrate showed a TCF of approximately 810 ppm/°C. This significantly higher sensitivity is attributed to the pronounced thermal expansion of the underlying polymer, which imposes additional strain on the functional layer, modifying its temperature-dependent behavior. This principle applies directly to resistors on printed circuit boards or flexible electronics, where substrate CTE (Coefficient of Thermal Expansion) mismatch is a critical design consideration.
  • Sensor Degradation: In NTC temperature sensors, the TCR can drift or the sensor can fail due to various damage mechanisms. Prolonged exposure to temperatures beyond the sensor's specified range can cause irreversible changes in the ceramic microstructure, altering its resistance-temperature characteristic [14]. Other causes of damage include:
  • Thermal cycling-induced mechanical stress leading to crack formation
  • Chemical contamination or corrosion of the electrode materials
  • Moisture ingress, especially in poorly encapsulated sensors
  • Excessive electrical current causing self-heating and thermal runaway [14]

Measurement and Standardization

Accurate determination of TCR requires controlled temperature environments and precise resistance measurement, typically using a four-wire Kelvin connection to eliminate lead resistance errors. The component is placed in a temperature chamber, and its resistance is measured at multiple stabilized temperature points spanning the range of interest. The data is then fitted to a linear or polynomial model to extract the α and β coefficients. International standards, such as IEC 60539 and MIL-PRF-23648, define test methods and specifications for thermistors and other resistive components, ensuring consistency and reliability in reported TCR values [14].

Importance in Circuit Design and Applications

Understanding and accounting for TCR is paramount in electronic design. In precision analog circuits, such as voltage references, instrumentation amplifiers, and data converters, resistors with low, matched TCRs are essential to maintain accuracy over temperature. In contrast, components with high, predictable TCRs are exploited for temperature sensing, compensation, and control. For example, a copper wire's positive TCR is used in resistance temperature detectors (RTDs), while the high negative TCR of a thermistor is used for inrush current limiting and temperature compensation in oscillators. The failure to properly consider TCR can lead to circuit drift, measurement errors, and system instability, underscoring its role as a first-order parameter in reliable electronic engineering [13][14].

History

The conceptual and practical understanding of how electrical resistance changes with temperature—a phenomenon later formalized as the Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR)—evolved over centuries, driven by the intertwined needs of scientific measurement, materials science, and industrial application. Its history is marked by the development of instruments to measure high temperatures, the discovery of materials with predictable and useful thermal-electrical properties, and the refinement of theoretical models to describe the underlying physics.

Early Foundations and Pyrometric Measurement (18th–19th Centuries)

The earliest practical engagement with the relationship between temperature and material properties relevant to electrical resistance stemmed from the field of pyrometry. In 1786, the English potter and entrepreneur Josiah Wedgwood invented a pyrometer to gauge the extreme temperatures inside pottery kilns, a critical variable for consistent ceramic quality [15]. His device relied not on electrical properties but on the uniform thermal contraction of a clay piece; the degree of shrinkage provided a measure of the heat exposure [15]. While not an electrical measurement, Wedgwood's work established the critical industrial need for reliable high-temperature measurement and indirectly highlighted how a material's physical dimensions—a factor in its eventual electrical resistance—could be systematically altered by heat. This period laid the groundwork for recognizing temperature as a quantifiable variable that produced repeatable changes in material states. The 19th century brought the foundational discoveries that would later explain TCR at a microscopic level. In 1821, Thomas Johann Seebeck discovered the thermoelectric effect, demonstrating that a temperature difference across a junction of two dissimilar metals could generate an electromotive force. This was a direct, measurable link between thermal and electrical phenomena. Later, in 1851, William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) established that a temperature gradient along a single conductor could also produce a voltage, an effect now known as the Thomson effect. These discoveries moved the understanding beyond simple observation to a theoretical framework connecting heat flow and charge carrier behavior, which is central to the mechanism of TCR.

Emergence of Quantitative Theory and Material Classification (Late 19th–Early 20th Century)

The formal, quantitative study of resistance's temperature dependence accelerated with the maturation of electromagnetic theory and improved laboratory techniques. A pivotal advancement was the derivation of the temperature dependence of resistivity for pure metals. The classical model, developed in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, described resistivity (ρ) as proportional to absolute temperature (T) for metals: ρ ∝ T. This linear relationship arises from the increased scattering of conduction electrons by lattice vibrations (phonons), which grow more energetic with temperature. The first-order approximation for the change in resistance, R(T) = R₀[1 + α(T - T₀)], where α is the TCR, became a standard engineering formula during this era. This model successfully described the positive temperature coefficient (PTC) behavior of most pure metals like copper and platinum, which see their resistance increase predictably with temperature. Concurrently, the discovery of materials exhibiting a negative temperature coefficient (NTC) presented a new puzzle and opportunity. While the PTC of metals was well-explained by increased electron scattering, the NTC effect—where resistance decreases as temperature rises—required a different mechanism. This was first systematically observed in certain semiconductor materials like silver sulfide, as noted by Michael Faraday in 1833, but not understood. The development of quantum mechanics and band theory in the early 20th century provided the explanation: in semiconductors and insulators, rising temperature excites more charge carriers (electrons) across the band gap, thereby increasing conductivity and lowering resistance. This fundamental distinction between metallic (PTC) and semiconducting (NTC) behavior became a cornerstone of materials science and electronics.

Industrialization of Thermistors and Standardization (Mid-20th Century)

The practical application of NTC materials surged in the 1930s and 1940s with the invention and commercialization of the thermistor (a portmanteau of "thermal resistor"). Samuel Ruben is credited with inventing the first commercially viable thermistor in 1930. These ceramic semiconductors, typically composed of oxides of manganese, nickel, cobalt, copper, and zinc, exhibited a large, predictable, and negative α [14]. Their high sensitivity made them ideal for temperature measurement, control, and compensation circuits. The development of stable, reproducible NTC thermistor formulations became a major focus of materials research, as their performance was highly dependent on the precise composition and sintering process of the mixed metal oxides [14]. This period also saw the critical standardization of reference temperatures for TCR specification. The value of α is inherently dependent on the reference temperature T₀. While 0°C (273.15 K) was used historically, 20°C and 25°C became industry standards, aligning with typical laboratory conditions. The adoption of standard reference temperatures allowed for consistent comparison and specification of materials across manufacturers and applications, from precision resistors to temperature sensors.

Advanced Materials and Microelectronics (Late 20th Century–Present)

The latter half of the 20th century demanded new materials with tailored TCR properties for advanced electronics. For precision analog circuits and stable voltage references, resistors with a near-zero TCR were essential. This led to the development of specialized alloys like manganin (Cu-Mn-Ni) and Evanohm (Ni-Cr with additives), whose compositions were engineered to balance the competing effects that cause resistance change, resulting in a TCR of just a few parts per million per degree Celsius (ppm/°C). In the realm of integrated circuits, the TCR of thin-film and diffused resistors became a critical design parameter. The coefficient for these components depends not only on the bulk material properties but also on film stress, geometry, and substrate interaction. For instance, the Temperature Coefficient of Frequency (TCF) for a surface acoustic wave device on a flexible polymeric substrate was measured at approximately 810 ppm/°C, a value significantly higher than the 59 ppm/°C observed for an identical device on a rigid substrate. This dramatic difference was attributed to the dominant influence of the substrate's thermal expansion, illustrating how system-level design can overshadow intrinsic material TCR in microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) and flexible electronics [3]. Furthermore, the field of nuclear reactor physics made a crucial operational distinction based on the physical cause of the effect: the fuel temperature coefficient (or Doppler coefficient), which arises from changes in nuclear fuel cross-section with temperature, and the moderator temperature coefficient, stemming from changes in the density and moderating efficiency of the coolant/moderator. This distinction underscores that "temperature coefficient" is a functional descriptor whose physical origins must be precisely defined for safety-critical analysis.

Contemporary Research and Future Directions

Modern research continues to explore extreme and engineered TCR behaviors. Posistors (PTC thermistors), often made from doped barium titanate, exhibit a sharp, nonlinear increase in resistance at a specific Curie temperature, making them useful as self-resetting fuses or heating elements. On the frontiers of materials science, the study of strongly correlated electron systems, such as some transition metal oxides, has revealed materials that can undergo metal-insulator transitions with temperature, leading to colossal changes in resistance. Today, the historical journey from Wedgwood's kiln to nanoscale thin films encapsulates the evolution of TCR from an observed phenomenon to a fundamental, design-governing material parameter. Its history reflects the broader progress of electromagnetism, quantum theory, and materials engineering, remaining central to innovation in fields ranging from consumer electronics to aerospace and energy systems.

Principles

The temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR) is governed by fundamental physical principles that link microscopic atomic behavior to macroscopic electrical properties. These principles differ significantly between material classes—metals, semiconductors, and ceramics—leading to both positive and negative TCR values. The underlying mechanisms involve the interplay between charge carrier density and carrier mobility, both of which are temperature-dependent [6][13].

Physical Mechanisms by Material Class

In pure metals, resistance increases with temperature, resulting in a positive TCR. This behavior originates from the lattice vibration of atoms, or phonons. As temperature rises, atomic thermal agitation increases, causing more frequent and severe collisions between the conduction electrons and the lattice ions. This enhanced scattering reduces the mean free path of electrons, thereby increasing resistivity [6]. For most common metals like copper and aluminum, the TCR (α) at 20°C falls within a range of approximately +0.003 to +0.004 per kelvin (K⁻¹) or per degree Celsius (°C⁻¹) [4][5]. This positive coefficient is a direct consequence of the dominant scattering mechanism. In intrinsic semiconductors and many ceramic materials, resistance decreases with temperature, producing a negative temperature coefficient (NTC). This inverse relationship is governed by a different principle: the exponential increase in the number of intrinsic charge carriers (electrons and holes) with temperature. The thermal energy promotes electrons from the valence band into the conduction band, dramatically increasing carrier density (n). This increase in n typically outweighs any concurrent decrease in carrier mobility (μ) caused by increased scattering, leading to a net decrease in resistivity (ρ), since ρ ∝ 1/(nμ) [13]. This mechanism is central to the function of NTC thermistors. For some specialized ceramics and doped semiconductors, a positive temperature coefficient (PTC) effect can occur. In certain polycrystalline materials like doped barium titanate, resistance can increase dramatically over a narrow temperature range near a structural phase transition (e.g., the Curie point). This is often explained by the Heywang model, where potential barriers form at grain boundaries. As temperature rises, the dielectric constant changes, altering the barrier height and causing a steep increase in resistance [16]. This results in a highly non-linear, positive TCR within a specific temperature window.

Mathematical Description Beyond First-Order Approximation

While the first-order linear approximation is standard for many engineering applications, it is an oversimplification for materials with strong non-linear behavior or over wide temperature ranges. A more accurate representation for many materials, especially semiconductors and ceramics, is the Steinhart-Hart equation: 1/T = A + B(ln R) + C(ln R)³ where T is the absolute temperature in kelvins, R is the resistance, and A, B, and C are material-specific Steinhart-Hart coefficients [4]. This empirical model provides a much closer fit to the resistance-temperature characteristic of NTC thermistors. For metals at very high purity or over extended ranges, the resistivity (ρ) can be better modeled by the Bloch–Grüneisen formula, which accounts for the temperature dependence of electron-phonon scattering. The relationship often follows a power law (ρ ∝ Tⁿ) at temperatures above the Debye temperature, where n typically approaches 5 for ideal metals, though it is closer to 1 for many practical alloys over common operating ranges [6].

Distinction in Complex Systems: Fuel vs. Moderator

The principle of TCR extends beyond simple electronic components to complex engineered systems, where the physical origin of the temperature feedback is critical. A clear example is found in nuclear reactor design, which distinguishes between the fuel temperature coefficient and the moderator temperature coefficient. Although both describe how reactivity changes with temperature, they are governed by "better-defined physical reasons" [1].

  • Fuel Temperature Coefficient (Doppler Coefficient): This is typically negative and arises from the Doppler broadening of nuclear resonance absorption peaks in fuel isotopes like U-238. As fuel temperature increases, the thermal motion of nuclei broadens the energy range at which they can absorb neutrons. This increases the probability of resonance absorption (non-fission capture), effectively removing more neutrons from the fission chain reaction and providing a crucial, immediate negative feedback for reactor stability [1].
  • Moderator Temperature Coefficient: This coefficient can be positive or negative and is primarily driven by changes in the moderator's density and its effectiveness in thermalizing neutrons. For light water reactors, increasing temperature decreases water density, which reduces neutron moderation and leakage. The net effect on reactivity depends on the core design but is a slower-acting mechanism compared to the Doppler effect [1]. This distinction underscores that the sign and magnitude of a temperature coefficient are not merely empirical observations but are direct consequences of specific, quantifiable physical processes inherent to the system's materials and geometry.

Conversion and Comparative Scaling

The numerical value of TCR is dependent on the reference temperature and the units of temperature change. As the kelvin (K) is the SI base unit of thermodynamic temperature, TCR is fundamentally expressed in K⁻¹ [4]. However, because the size of one degree Celsius is equal to one kelvin, the numerical value of a TCR per °C⁻¹ is identical to its value per K⁻¹ [5]. This multiplicative conversion factor of 1 simplifies interchange but requires careful specification of the reference scale in precise work. The impact of different TCR values on resistance change can be understood through comparative scaling. For instance, a material with a TCR of +2000 ppm/K (or +0.002 K⁻¹) experiences a resistance change that is twice as large as a material with a TCR of +1000 ppm/K for the same ΔT. This relationship is not linear across all values but illustrates relative sensitivity. A converter demonstrating such proportional relationships shows sequences like "2X of 1 ▶ 1/2X of 1 ▶ 5X of 1 ▶ 1/5X of 1 ▶ 8X of 1 ▶ 1/8X of 1" [3]. This notation conceptually represents how a given TCR value (1X) compares to values that are multiples or fractions of it, highlighting the orders-of-magnitude differences that can exist between materials—from the low ppm/K values of precision metal alloys to the high percentage-per-Kelvin values of thermistors [3][6][13].

Material Synthesis and Structural Influence

The TCR of a material is not an intrinsic property of its constituent elements alone but is critically determined by its microstructure, which is a product of the synthesis process. For ceramic NTC materials, such as those in the Ba₃CoNb₂O₉ system, the "conventional solid-state reaction method" is commonly employed [16]. This process involves high-temperature calcination of mixed oxide powders to form a homogeneous perovskite or spinel structure. The resulting TCR is highly sensitive to:

  • The exact stoichiometry and doping levels.
    • The sintering temperature and atmosphere, which control grain growth, density, and oxygen vacancy concentration.
    • The distribution and chemistry of grain boundaries [16]. Minor deviations in synthesis can lead to significant variations in the electrical properties, including the magnitude and stability of the TCR. This underscores the principle that TCR is a manufacturable property, engineered through precise control of chemistry and processing to achieve a target resistance-temperature characteristic for specific applications like temperature sensing or inrush current limiting [13][16].

Types

The temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR) is not a monolithic property but varies significantly based on material composition, physical structure, and the underlying conduction mechanism. These variations allow for classification along several dimensions, including the sign of the coefficient, the material class, the operational temperature range, and the physical origin of the effect. Standardized classifications, such as those in IEC 60539, help categorize these materials for industrial and scientific application [17].

By Sign of Coefficient

The most fundamental classification distinguishes materials based on whether their resistance increases or decreases with rising temperature.

  • Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC): Materials with a PTC exhibit an increase in electrical resistance as temperature rises. This behavior is characteristic of most pure metals, where increased lattice vibrations (phonons) scatter conduction electrons more effectively, reducing mobility [18]. The PTC effect in metals is typically linear over a broad temperature range and is quantified by a positive alpha (α) value, often in the range of +3000 to +6000 ppm/K for common conductors like copper.
  • Negative Temperature Coefficient (NTC): Materials with an NTC show a decrease in resistance with increasing temperature. This is the hallmark of most semiconductors, ceramics, and certain disordered materials [17]. The effect is often highly non-linear and can be several orders of magnitude larger than the PTC effect in metals. For example, NTC thermistor materials can have α values on the order of -30,000 to -60,000 ppm/K near room temperature [17]. The primary physical reason, as noted earlier, is the exponential increase in charge carrier concentration (n) with temperature in semiconducting materials, which overwhelms any concurrent decrease in carrier mobility.

By Material Class and Conduction Mechanism

The sign and magnitude of TCR are intrinsically linked to the material's electronic structure and dominant charge transport process.

  • Metallic Conductors: In pure metals and most alloys, resistance arises primarily from electron scattering by lattice imperfections and thermal vibrations. The temperature-dependent component follows the Bloch–Grüneisen formula, leading to a nearly linear PTC at temperatures above the Debye temperature. Alloys like Constantan (45% Nickel, 55% Copper) are engineered to have a very low, nearly negligible TCR over a specific temperature range, making them critical for precision resistors and strain gauges where minimal drift is required [21][22].
  • Semiconductors and Ceramics: These materials display NTC behavior due to their band gap. Intrinsic semiconductors see carrier concentration rise exponentially with temperature (n ∝ exp(-E_g/2kT)). Extrinsic semiconductors show this effect once temperature is sufficient to ionize dopants. Polycrystalline ceramic NTC thermistors, often based on transition metal oxides like Mn, Co, Ni, and Fe, operate on a hopping or tunneling conduction mechanism between grains, which is also strongly thermally activated [16][17].
  • Disordered and Nanostructured Materials: Materials with high defect densities, amorphous structures, or nanoscale features can exhibit anomalous conduction. For instance, nanostructured gold resistive switching films have demonstrated an NTC effect attributed to the localization of conduction electrons at a high density of extended defects and grain boundaries across the measured temperature range [20]. This represents a distinct class where disorder, rather than intrinsic semiconductor properties, governs the TCR.

By Operational Temperature Range and Stability

Materials are also classified and selected based on their reliable operational temperature window, a critical factor in application design.

  • Standard-Range Materials: Most commercial NTC thermistors and metal film resistors are designed for operation between approximately -50°C and +150°C [17]. Within this range, their characteristics are stable and predictable.
  • High-Temperature Materials: Applications in aerospace, exhaust gas treatment, geothermal detection, and industrial processes require sensors and components that function reliably above 300°C [16]. Specialized high-temperature NTC ceramics, such as those based on Ba₃CoNb₂O₉, are developed for this purpose, with formulations focused on structural and electrical stability at extreme temperatures [16]. Similarly, the performance of magnetic materials like SmCo magnets degrades significantly beyond their rated temperature range, highlighting the importance of component-specific temperature limits [19].
  • Materials with Reversible vs. Irreversible Effects: Some components exhibit reversible TCR, where resistance changes predictably with temperature cycling. Others may suffer from irreversible changes due to aging, oxidation, or structural phase transitions. Understanding this distinction is vital for calibration and long-term reliability [18].

By Physical Origin in Specialized Contexts

In certain fields, the classification of TCR is tied to specific physical phenomena rather than just material composition.

  • Nuclear Reactor Coefficients: In reactor physics, the temperature coefficient of reactivity is a critical safety and stability parameter. Here, a key distinction is made between the fuel temperature coefficient (Doppler coefficient) and the moderator temperature coefficient. The fuel coefficient is inherently prompt and negative in most designs, as increased fuel temperature broadens neutron absorption resonances. The moderator coefficient, which can be positive or negative depending on design, relates to changes in moderator density and its neutron-moderating efficiency. This classification is based on clearly defined and separate physical mechanisms with distinct time constants and impacts on reactor control.
  • Substrate-Dependent Effects in Microelectronics: The effective TCR of a thin-film resistor or a surface acoustic wave (SAW) device is not solely a property of the film itself but is influenced by the substrate. For example, a Rayleigh wave SAW device on a flexible polymeric substrate was found to have a temperature coefficient of frequency (TCF) of approximately 810 ppm/°C. This was significantly higher than the 59 ppm/°C observed for a similar device on a rigid substrate. The increased sensitivity is attributed to the larger thermal expansion coefficient of the underlying polymer, demonstrating how the composite system's TCR can be classified and dominated by non-electrical, mechanical properties of the support structure.

Standardized Classifications

International standards provide formal classifications to ensure consistency. IEC 60539, which covers direct heated negative temperature coefficient thermistors, classifies them by:

  • Material Type: E.g., metallized surface contact, radial lead, or disc type.
  • Resistance-Temperature Characteristic: Specified by a B-value (β parameter) derived from the Steinhart-Hart equation, which describes the non-linear R-T curve.
  • Stability and Tolerance Classes: Defining allowable drift and resistance deviation over time and temperature cycles [17]. This multi-dimensional taxonomy—encompassing sign, material, mechanism, temperature range, and application-specific origins—provides the framework for selecting the appropriate substance or component with the desired TCR characteristic for any given technological need.

Characteristics

The Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR) is a fundamental material property whose practical implications are defined by its magnitude, sign, and stability across operational temperature ranges. These characteristics determine component selection for specific applications, from precision measurement to extreme environment operation.

Sign and Magnitude: PTC vs. NTC

The sign of the TCR categorizes materials into two primary classes. Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC) materials, which include most pure metals and certain ceramics, exhibit an increase in resistance with rising temperature. For instance, the TCR of polycrystalline radio frequency sputtered aluminium films is a classic example of a metallic PTC [23]. Conversely, Negative Temperature Coefficient (NTC) materials demonstrate a decrease in resistance as temperature increases. NTC thermistors, which are resistive sensors whose resistance decreases significantly as temperature rises, are the most widespread application of this property [8]. The magnitude of the TCR, whether positive or negative, directly dictates the sensitivity of a device to temperature fluctuations. A material with a large negative TCR, such as a typical NTC thermistor, will experience a more pronounced resistance change per degree than a material with a small positive TCR, like many metal alloys.

Material Composition and Alloying Effects

The TCR of a material is not an immutable property but can be precisely engineered through composition and processing. Alloying is a primary method for tailoring TCR. A quintessential example is Constantan, a copper-nickel alloy usually consisting of 55% copper and 45% nickel, with specific minor amounts of additional elements added to achieve precisely controlled, nearly constant values for the temperature coefficient of resistivity [21]. This extraordinary alloy revolutionised various industrial and scientific applications by providing a stable, low TCR essential for precision resistors and strain gauges [22]. In thin-film and nanostructured materials, deposition parameters and microstructure exert significant influence. Research on polycrystalline aluminium films shows that their resistivity and TCR are affected by sputtering conditions and grain structure [23]. In more complex systems, such as nanostructured gold resistive switching films, electrical conduction and a negative temperature coefficient of resistance arise from the formation and destruction of conducting junctions between isolated nanoparticles, a behavior linked to neuromorphic properties [20].

Operational Range and Environmental Stability

A critical characteristic is the usable temperature range over which the TCR remains predictable and stable. Standard NTC thermistors are typically rated for operation up to approximately 150°C [7]. However, specialized applications demand materials with stable characteristics under more extreme conditions. In fields such as aerospace, exhaust gas treatment, geothermal detection, and explosion sites, high-temperature thermistors with working temperatures above 300°C are required for realizing temperature measurement and control. This necessitates materials and designs where the TCR and base resistance do not degrade or become unstable at these elevated temperatures. Beyond temperature, environmental and electrical stress factors impact long-term stability. For example, electrical overstress occurs when a sensor is exposed to voltage or current levels beyond its rated specifications, often due to power surges or improper circuit design, which can permanently alter its resistance-TCR characteristics [17]. This underscores that the documented TCR is only valid within the component's specified electrical and environmental operating limits.

Comparative Performance in Extreme Conditions

The performance of materials under thermal stress highlights the importance of a stable, well-characterized TCR. This is evident not only in resistive materials but also in related functional materials where magnetic or other properties are temperature-dependent. For instance, in permanent magnet technology, samarium-cobalt (SmCo) magnets are noted for their superior temperature stability, maintaining magnetic performance under extreme thermal conditions where other magnet types would significantly degrade [19]. While this example pertains to magnetic coercivity rather than electrical resistance, it illustrates the broader engineering principle that a low or predictable temperature coefficient of a key property—whether resistance, magnetic strength, or dimensional change (coefficient of thermal expansion)—is paramount for reliability in demanding environments. Systems designed for high-temperature operation must integrate materials whose critical coefficients are either minimal or precisely known across the entire operational envelope.

Application-Defined Characteristics

The required characteristics of TCR are ultimately defined by the application. These needs can be broadly categorized:

  • Precision and Stability: Applications like precision measurement bridges, reference resistors, and strain gauges demand a TCR as close to zero as possible. Alloys like Constantan are employed specifically for this characteristic [21][22].
  • High Sensitivity: For temperature sensing and compensation, a large, predictable TCR is desirable. NTC thermistors are widely used for temperature measurement and control due to their high sensitivity, fast response, and cost-effectiveness [8]. Their large negative TCR provides a strong signal for temperature changes.
  • Circuit Protection: PTC thermistors with a sharp, nonlinear increase in resistance at a critical temperature (the "switching" point) are used as resettable fuses or overcurrent protection devices, leveraging a specific, non-linear TCR characteristic.
  • Stability in Harsh Environments: Applications involving high temperatures, thermal cycling, or corrosive atmospheres require materials whose TCR does not drift over time and is stable against environmental degradation, as noted in high-temperature thermistor applications.

Anomalous and Complex Behaviors

Beyond the simple linear PTC of metals and the exponential NTC of semiconductors, more complex TCR behaviors exist in advanced material systems. These often arise from competing physical mechanisms or unique microstructures. For example, the anomalous electrical conduction and negative temperature coefficient of resistance observed in nanostructured gold films is attributed to electron transport governed by the formation and destruction of conducting junctions between isolated nanoparticles [20]. Such systems operate in a weak-coupling regime, and their electrical behavior—and thus their effective TCR—can be dynamic, history-dependent, and tunable, conferring properties useful for neuromorphic computing applications [20]. These behaviors highlight that the TCR is not always a simple, intrinsic material constant but can be an emergent property of a system's specific structure and operational state.

Applications

The temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR) is a critical parameter that dictates the selection and performance of materials across a vast spectrum of technologies. Its applications extend from fundamental temperature sensing and compensation in everyday electronics to sophisticated control and safety mechanisms in high-stakes industrial and scientific domains. The sign and magnitude of a material's TCR—whether positive (PTC) or negative (NTC)—determine its suitability for specific functions, enabling precise thermal management, measurement, and system stabilization [9].

Temperature Sensing and Measurement

The most direct application of TCR is in the construction of resistive temperature sensors, where a material's predictable change in resistance with temperature is calibrated to provide an electrical signal proportional to thermal conditions. NTC thermistors, which exhibit a large, negative TCR, are particularly valued for high-sensitivity measurements over moderate temperature ranges. Their resistance can decrease by 3-5% per °C, making them exceptionally responsive [9]. These components are ubiquitous in consumer and industrial systems for monitoring and control:

  • Climate Control Systems: Embedded in thermostats for heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) to regulate ambient temperature [9].
  • Consumer Appliances: Used in kettles, coffee makers, refrigerators, and smartphones to prevent overheating and manage operational cycles [9].
  • Automotive Electronics: Monitor coolant, oil, and cabin air temperatures for engine management and passenger comfort [9].
  • Medical Devices: Provide precise temperature readings in diagnostic equipment and patient monitoring systems [9]. For applications requiring extreme precision or a wider temperature range, platinum resistance temperature detectors (RTDs) are preferred. Platinum has a stable and repeatable positive TCR of approximately +0.00385 Ω/Ω/°C, and its resistance follows a well-characterized polynomial relationship with temperature, making it the international standard for temperatures from -200°C to over 600°C [23]. The historical pursuit of accurate pyrometry, exemplified by devices like the Wedgwood pyrometer used to gauge kiln temperatures in the 18th century, has evolved into modern TCR-based sensing [15].

Thermal Compensation and Circuit Stability

In electronic circuit design, uncontrolled resistance variation with temperature is a primary source of error and drift. Engineers deliberately utilize components with specific TCRs to counteract these undesirable effects, a practice known as temperature compensation. A common strategy involves pairing components with opposing TCRs to create a network with a net TCR near zero. For instance, a resistor with a carefully chosen PTC can be placed in series or parallel with a critical NTC element to flatten the overall resistance curve over a target temperature range [23]. This is essential for the stability of:

  • Precision Voltage References and Oscillators: Circuits that must maintain a constant output frequency or voltage regardless of ambient temperature changes.
  • Measurement Bridges: Used in strain gauges and transducer systems, where thermal drift in bridge arm resistors can obscure the signal of interest.
  • Amplifier Biasing Networks: Ensuring transistor operating points remain stable across temperature to prevent gain drift or distortion. Thin-film resistors, often made from materials like nickel-chromium (NiCr) or tantalum nitride (TaN), are engineered to have very low TCRs, sometimes as small as ±5 ppm/°C, for use in high-precision analog and digital circuits where minimal drift is paramount [23]. Conversely, the property of temperature-independent elasticity, as found in alloys like Elinvar (Fe52Ni36Cr12), is valuable in mechanical timekeeping and instrumentation, representing a parallel principle of thermal compensation in the mechanical domain [11].

Current Limiting and Over-Temperature Protection

Materials with a highly nonlinear positive TCR (PTC) are exploited as self-regulating current limiters and resettable fuses. Certain conductive polymers and ceramic semiconductors exhibit a sharp increase in resistance at a specific switching temperature, often due to a phase change or a rapid reduction in charge carrier mobility. When excessive current flows, Joule heating raises the component's temperature, triggering this transition to a high-resistance state that effectively limits the current. Once the fault condition is removed and the device cools, its resistance drops back to the normal low value. This reversible operation is integral to safety in [9]:

  • Power Supplies and Motor Starters: Protecting against inrush currents.
  • Consumer Electronics: Safeguarding USB ports, battery packs, and charging circuits.
  • Automotive Wiring Harnesses: Preventing short circuits from causing fires.

Critical Role in Nuclear Reactor Safety

One of the most significant safety applications of a negative TCR phenomenon is in nuclear fission reactors, specifically through the fuel temperature coefficient (FTC) or Doppler coefficient. This is a measure of how reactor reactivity changes with the temperature of the nuclear fuel (e.g., uranium dioxide). As fuel temperature rises, the increased thermal motion of uranium-238 nuclei broadens the energy range at which they can absorb neutrons (Doppler broadening). This leads to increased neutron absorption (a negative reactivity insertion), which inherently slows the fission chain reaction, providing a crucial passive safety feedback mechanism [24][26]. A prompt negative FTC is a fundamental design requirement for all modern reactors, as it ensures that an unintended increase in power output will produce physical effects that counteract the rise, enhancing inherent stability [24][25]. This principle underscores how macroscopic material properties rooted in atomic physics—directly analogous to electrical TCR—are engineered for large-scale system safety.

Aerospace, Communications, and Defense

The extreme environmental demands of aerospace, telecommunications, and defense systems necessitate components with predictable and stable thermal performance. TCR management is vital in these fields for ensuring reliability under thermal cycling from -55°C to over 125°C [9]. Applications include:

  • Satellite Systems: Precision resistors with low TCR ensure signal integrity in communication and navigation electronics exposed to the temperature extremes of space.
  • Avionics: Sensors and control systems in aircraft must function reliably from ground operations to high-altitude flight conditions.
  • Radio Frequency (RF) Circuits: In communication systems, the stability of filters and impedance-matching networks depends on components with minimal TCR to prevent frequency drift. The TCR of sputtered aluminium films, for example, has been studied for use in such RF components [23].
  • Guidance and Control Systems: Inertial measurement units and other sensitive instrumentation require compensated circuits to maintain accuracy.

Power Industry and Energy Management

In the generation, transmission, and distribution of electrical power, thermal effects governed by TCR principles are central to both operation and monitoring. NTC thermistors are used to monitor winding temperatures in transformers, generators, and motors, preventing insulation failure due to overheating [9]. Furthermore, the concept extends to grid stability and advanced reactor designs. The inherent safety provided by negative temperature coefficients in nuclear fuel, as discussed, is a cornerstone of reactor physics [26]. This principle is also a key consideration in the development of next-generation Small Modular Reactors (SMRs), where passive safety systems relying on physical properties like negative feedback coefficients are a major design focus [25].

Materials Science and Metrology

Beyond direct engineering applications, the measurement and analysis of TCR is a fundamental tool in materials characterization. It provides insights into conduction mechanisms, impurity levels, and structural homogeneity. For example, measuring the TCR of a thin metal film can reveal information about its grain structure, purity, and the dominance of surface or grain boundary scattering effects, which deviate from the bulk metal behavior described by the Bloch–Grüneisen formula [23]. In metrology, standard resistors maintained at constant temperature in oil baths are used to realize the ohm, demonstrating how controlling thermal expansion and TCR is essential to defining fundamental units [12].

Considerations

The practical application and measurement of the Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR) involve several critical technical considerations beyond its fundamental definition. These encompass measurement standards, material-specific complexities, and the nuanced interpretation of TCR values in real-world engineering contexts.

Measurement Standards and Reference Temperature

While the selection of a reference temperature (T₀) is a prerequisite for TCR calculation, the practical implementation of this measurement requires strict adherence to standardized conditions to ensure reproducibility and comparability between different materials and laboratories. The TCR value is highly sensitive to the exact temperature at which it is measured, as the coefficient α itself can be temperature-dependent, particularly for non-linear materials like thermistors or certain alloys [1]. Consequently, published TCR specifications are meaningless without a clearly stated reference temperature. Standardized test procedures, such as those outlined by the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), specify not only the reference point but also the permissible temperature range for the measurement, the thermal stabilization time required for the sample, and the techniques for minimizing parasitic thermal voltages in the measurement circuit [2]. For thin-film materials, which are prevalent in integrated circuits and sensors, additional factors become significant. The TCR can be influenced by film thickness, deposition method, and substrate interactions, as variations in grain structure and defect density alter the dominant electron scattering mechanisms [1]. This necessitates that TCR characterization for such materials reports the specific fabrication conditions alongside the measured value.

Material Exceptions and Anomalous Behavior

Building on the principles discussed above for different material classes, certain substances exhibit TCR behavior that deviates markedly from the typical positive or negative trends. A historically significant exception is the Elinvar alloy family, with a nominal composition of Fe-36Ni-12Cr, which demonstrates an almost negligible TCR over a considerable temperature range [3]. This "elinvar effect" arises from a fortuitous compensation between several competing factors: the normal positive contribution from lattice vibration scattering and a negative contribution from a spontaneous magnetization effect that varies with temperature. The result is a net coefficient that can be tuned to near zero, a property that was crucial for the stability of mechanical timekeeping components before the advent of electronics [3]. Other anomalies exist in materials undergoing phase transitions. For instance, some conductive polymers and metal oxides exhibit a sudden, orders-of-magnitude change in resistance at a critical temperature, a phenomenon utilized in positive temperature coefficient (PTC) resettable fuses. In these cases, assigning a single TCR value is impractical; instead, the resistance-temperature curve must be characterized in its entirety [2].

Interpretation and Application in Circuit Design

As noted earlier, TCR management is vital for circuit stability. However, effectively applying TCR data requires understanding its limitations and secondary effects. The first-order linear approximation, R(T) = R₀[1 + α(T - T₀)], is sufficient for small temperature excursions around T₀ or for materials with a truly linear response, like platinum over limited ranges. For most semiconductors and thermistors, this model fails over wide temperature spans. For negative temperature coefficient (NTC) thermistors, the resistance follows an approximately exponential relationship with temperature, often modeled by the Steinhart-Hart equation: 1/T = A + B(ln R) + C(ln R)³, where A, B, and C are device-specific coefficients [2]. Using a single, constant α value for such a device would introduce significant error. Furthermore, in precision analog circuits, designers must consider not only the nominal TCR of individual resistors but also the tracking of TCR between matched components. The drift of a differential amplifier, for example, depends more on the difference in TCR between its input pair of resistors than on their absolute TCR values. Consequently, manufacturers specify "TCR tracking" for matched resistor networks, which is typically an order of magnitude tighter than the absolute TCR specification (e.g., ±5 ppm/°C tracking vs. ±25 ppm/°C absolute) [2].

Self-Heating and Power Derating

A critical, often overlooked consideration is the effect of self-heating on the effective TCR in operation. When current flows through a resistive component, Joule heating (P = I²R) raises its temperature above the ambient. This creates a coupled problem: the resistance depends on temperature via TCR, and the temperature depends on the power dissipated in the resistance. The steady-state temperature rise is governed by the component's thermal resistance to its environment. For a resistor dissipating power P, the temperature rise ΔT_rise is approximately P × R_θ, where R_θ is the thermal resistance in °C/W [2]. The actual resistance in-circuit thus becomes R(T_ambient + ΔT_rise). This effect is particularly pronounced for components with high TCR and poor heat dissipation, such as certain NTC thermistors used in current-sensing applications. If not properly accounted for, self-heating can lead to a runaway condition in PTC materials or measurement errors in sensor applications. Datasheets for precision resistors and thermistors therefore often include power derating curves or maximum permissible load curves that account for this thermal interaction [2].

Long-Term Stability and Aging

The TCR of a component is not a permanently fixed property but can drift over time due to aging effects, especially under thermal cycling or continuous high-temperature operation. In thin-film and metal alloy resistors, long-term stability is influenced by microstructural changes such as oxidation, interdiffusion of layers, or relaxation of mechanical stresses induced during manufacturing [1]. These processes can subtly alter the dominant scattering mechanisms, leading to a gradual shift in the measured TCR. For instance, a thin-film resistor may have an initial TCR of ±25 ppm/°C but exhibit an "end-of-life" TCR shift specification of an additional ±50 ppm/°C after 10,000 hours of operation at full rated power and temperature [2]. This long-term drift is a separate parameter from the initial TCR and must be considered in the reliability analysis of critical systems like aerospace electronics or medical instrumentation. Accelerated life testing at elevated temperatures is commonly used to model and predict these aging effects on TCR.

Composite and Non-Uniform Temperature Fields

In practical assemblies, a component may not experience a uniform temperature. For example, a surface-mount resistor on a printed circuit board (PCB) will have one terminal closer to a heat-producing integrated circuit than the other, creating a thermal gradient across the component body. If the resistive element itself is not perfectly homogeneous, this gradient can cause a non-uniform change in resistance along its length, leading to behavior that deviates from the prediction based on a single, averaged temperature. Similarly, in wire-wound resistors, the TCR of the conductive wire may differ from the TCR of the termination welds or the insulating substrate, making the overall TCR a composite value that depends on the precise measurement technique [2]. For the most demanding precision applications, such as metrology standards, these effects are minimized through the use of bifilar wound coils or specially designed strain-free mounts to ensure isothermal conditions during measurement and use.

References

  1. [1]Temperature Coefficient - an overviewhttps://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/temperature-coefficient
  2. [2]Temperature Coefficient of Resistancehttp://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electric/restmp.html
  3. [3]Temperature Coefficient of Resistance Converterhttps://www.unitsconverters.com/en/Temperature-Coefficient-Of-Resistance-Conversions/Measurement-1134
  4. [4]- kelvin - BIPMhttps://www.bipm.org/en/si-base-units/kelvin
  5. [5]Per Kelvin to Per Degree Celsiushttps://www.unitsconverters.com/en/Perkelvin-To-Perdegreecelsius/Unittounit-6304-6305
  6. [6]Technical Info on Riedon Resistors & Shunt Resistorshttps://riedon.com/technical/understanding-temperature/
  7. [7]How temperature-sensing NTC thermistors workhttps://www.allpcb.com/allelectrohub/how-temperaturesensing-ntc-thermistors-work
  8. [8]NTC Thermistor Applications for Temperature Sensing | DXMhttps://www.dxmht.com/case/ntc-thermistor-applications.html
  9. [9][PDF] characterization of new negative temperature coefficient 4coksv7693https://scispace.com/pdf/characterization-of-new-negative-temperature-coefficient-4coksv7693.pdf
  10. [10]A new mechanism for low and temperature-independent elastic modulushttps://www.nature.com/articles/srep11477
  11. [11]Fundamentals of Thermal Expansion and Thermal Contractionhttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5506936/
  12. [12]Temperature Coefficient of Resistance ② | What is a Resistor?https://techweb.rohm.com/product/passive-components/resistors/23752/
  13. [13]Temperature coefficienthttps://grokipedia.com/page/Temperature_coefficient
  14. [14]Wedgwood pyrometer, 1786 | Science Museum Group Collectionhttps://collection.sciencemuseumgroup.org.uk/objects/co1684/wedgwood-pyrometer-1786
  15. [15]Structural stability and electrical properties of Ba3CoNb2O9-based negative temperature coefficient sensitive ceramicshttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0272884219301257
  16. [16]What are the Causes of NTC Temperature Sensor Damage? - Ntcshiheng.comhttps://www.ntcshiheng.com/what-are-the-causes-of-ntc-temperature-sensor-damage
  17. [17][PDF] Understanding and Using Reversible Temperature Coefficients Constantinides Magnetics 2010 psn hi reshttps://www.arnoldmagnetics.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Understanding-and-Using-Reversible-Temperature-Coefficients-Constantinides-Magnetics-2010-psn-hi-res.pdf
  18. [18]The Superior Temperature Stability of SmCo Magnetshttps://www.stanfordmagnets.com/the-superior-temperature-stability-of-smco-magnets.html
  19. [19]Anomalous electrical conduction and negative temperature coefficient of resistance in nanostructured gold resistive switching filmshttps://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-76632-y
  20. [20]Constantan – 45Ni-55Cu - Properties and Uses | nuclear-power.comhttps://www.nuclear-power.com/nuclear-engineering/metals-what-are-metals/alloys-composition-properties-of-metal-alloys/nickel-alloys/constantan-45ni-55cu-properties-and-uses/
  21. [21]Constantan Wire: A Key Material for Precision Measurement and Engineeringhttps://www.advent-rm.com/en-GB/Articles/2024/11/Constantan-Wire-A-Key-Material-for-Precision-Measu
  22. [22]The temperature coefficient of resistivity of polycrystalline radio frequency sputtered aluminium filmshttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0040609077902875
  23. [23]Safety of Nuclear Power Reactorshttps://world-nuclear.org/information-library/safety-and-security/safety-of-plants/safety-of-nuclear-power-reactors
  24. [24]Technical Overview of Recent Developments in Small Modular Reactors in the United Stateshttps://arxiv.org/html/2504.02599v1
  25. [25]Fuel Temperature Coefficient - Doppler Coefficienthttps://www.nuclear-power.com/nuclear-power/reactor-physics/nuclear-fission-chain-reaction/reactivity-coefficients-reactivity-feedbacks/fuel-temperature-coefficient-doppler-coefficient/